Skip to content
← Back to articles
Portals
Custom Software

Custom vs Packaged Client Portals: A Decision Worksheet

Compare essential controls, weighted requirements and three-year ownership costs using the same client journey.

By Rupert GoughPublished Updated
Custom vs Packaged Client Portals: A Decision Worksheet

The practical answer

Test each option against the same client task and essential access controls. Use a weighted matrix for preferences and compare setup, operation, changes and exit before deciding.

Discuss your client or staff portal requirements, users and existing tools so we can define a useful website or web app scope. Discuss your website or app.

On this page 5 sections

Choose a portal by testing the client’s task and the firm’s responsibilities. A packaged portal can be the right answer when it already handles the important journey. Custom work is worth assessing when a valuable requirement remains unmet and the business can support the result.

Define the same trial for every option #

Use a fictional client with two entities and one delegated representative. They must sign in, find an outstanding document request, submit a file, see that it awaits review and get help. Staff must reject an incorrect file and later confirm completion. Try the same journey in an existing platform, a packaged alternative and any proposed custom design.

Use essential requirements before a score #

Some requirements are pass/fail gates: appropriate client separation, required access controls, supported data handling and a viable way to export the data. A high convenience score must not compensate for a failed essential control. Have the responsible business and technical people agree the gates.

Illustrative weighted requirements matrix; scores are invented, not vendor ratings
RequirementWeightOption A score / 5Option B score / 5Evidence needed
Client completes the request on a phone543Observed task completion, including help and errors
Staff review and exception handling435Wrong file, changed request and delegated access tests
Integration with the existing record342API permissions, duplicate handling and failed-update recovery
Weighted totalMaximum 6044 / 6041 / 60A provisional comparison only; essential gates and total cost still apply

Multiply weight by score and add the results: A is 20 + 12 + 12 = 44; B is 15 + 20 + 6 = 41. Change the weights to match your priorities and write down the evidence for each score. Do not let an impressive demo substitute for a failed permission test.

Compare three-year ownership costs #

Collect actual costs from current plans and scoped proposals
CostPackaged portalCustom or hybrid portal
Initial setupConfiguration, branding, data cleanup, migration and trainingDiscovery, design, implementation, integrations, migration and training
36 months of operationPlan, user/client/storage tiers and supportHosting, identity, storage, third-party licences and support
ChangesAdditional modules, plan upgrades and configurationDevelopment, dependency maintenance and integration changes
ExitExport coverage, file download and migration effortCode/data rights, account access, documentation and handover

Use consistent NZD and GST treatment, and show internal staff effort separately if it is not a cash expense. Compare current prices for the features actually required. A packaged product may still need implementation help; custom software still has providers and dependencies.

Consider a focused layer over an existing core #

You may keep the CRM, accounting system or document platform and add a small client-facing workflow. Decide which system owns each record, how identity maps between systems, what may be shared and how failed updates are resolved. A hybrid is a design option, not a guarantee of cheaper integration.

Include privacy and practical access #

Map what is collected, its purpose, source, recipients and retention. The Privacy Commissioner’s principles and indirect-collection guidance help frame the review. The firm must determine its actual obligations and any specialist requirements.

Download the portal requirements and cost comparison (CSV). Open in a spreadsheet or text editor; the example rows are illustrative.

Proceed when an option passes the essential controls, works for representative clients and has an affordable operating plan. If neither option does, narrow the first release or improve the process before committing.

A useful companion: Automation ROI Calculator.